September 21 2012: The day the social media dream died

  • Voices
  • September 21, 2017
  • Paul Catmur
September 21 2012: The day the social media dream died
Facebook

September 21 marks the five-year anniversary of the day when Facebook turned social media into just plain ‘media’. This date is probably worth noting, if not necessarily celebrating, as it marks the end of the dream of brands having unlimited conversations with their fans for free.

It was a classic switcheroo. Having convinced brands that they needed to purchase fans and then Likes, Facebook cut off the free access and started to charge brands to speak to the very fans that they had just paid for.

It started when Facebook first allowed businesses to have pages in 2007 and created a wild west for canny marketers. Brands could build their own page by using incentives (Like us and get a free T-shirt!’) to hook in ‘fans’ (or merely the shirtless) who were then reassigned as being ‘brand lovers’. The popular wisdom was that these fans were now happily settled in a community where they could chat forever about their shared favorite subject, say, a toilet cleaner.

It soon turned out that people didn’t have a whole bunch of things to say to each other about toilet cleaners, but this really didn’t matter. The brands had corralled together some unwary consumers who, having expressed a passing interest in the brand, could now be reached by any number of messages, all sent for free.

Although it wasn’t quite free, of course, because somebody was needed to keep the hastily assembled fans in line and stop the malcontents from getting bitchy about the toilet cleaner that had brought them together in the first place. No such skill-set existed, but a bunch of geeks who liked the sound of being paid for being on Facebook all day blinked in the sunlight as they left their darkened bedrooms and became the first ‘social media managers’.

Marketers, being creatures of discipline, were a little distrustful of the laissez-faire norms of social media and instead of the fast response that Facebook encourages were keen that their posts be as tightly controlled as any other of their brand communication. This naturally added another layer of work and meant that production costs, although relatively small, were unavoidably seen as out of proportion to a zero media cost.

This state of affairs existed happily for hundreds of years. Well, hundreds of years in digital terms, in reality, just a couple. Then out of the blue came the meteor that killed the dinosaurs. Facebook decided they’d had enough of providing free media to their friends in brands and pulled what has been called ‘one of the most lucrative grifts of all time’*. Having sucked in companies to invest in building their fan base, Facebook then changed the algorithms so that brands would no longer reach their fan base at will, and the organic reach melted away like teenagers at washing-up time. Facebook didn’t explain, they didn’t apologise, they just turned off the pipe and waited for someone to complain. They didn’t.

Instead of turning on Facebook, the brand owners shot the messenger instead. That they were no longer reaching their consumers for free was generally misattributed as being their agency’s fault. It was taken as a tacit demonstration of how all agencies really wanted to do was make TV ads. As if to confirm their guilt, agencies politely pointed out that they would now need a bunch of media money to reach the same people that they had been reaching before for free. This message was as well received as most agency requests for additional funds required to achieve the same results.

It took two years for Time magazine to notice and in 2014 they ran an article announcing that ‘The Free-Marketing Gravy Train Is Over on Facebook’. A Facebook spokesman came out with the disarmingly frank admission that “if businesses want to make sure that people see their content, the best strategy is, and has always been, paid advertising”. So there we had it. Facebook was not actually about having conversations with consumers it was about putting paid ads in front of them like every other medium. Ever get the feeling you’d been had?

This wasn’t a grand Machiavellian scheme by Facebook. The algorithm was switched in answer to a growing number of teens leaving Facebook because of the preponderance of posts from brands rather than friends. How did the all-knowing Facebook get into this problem in the first place? Well, Chaos Monkeys, the recently released book by Facebook insider Antonio Garcia Martinez, gives an interesting account of what Facebook is like behind the door of the Zuckerberg bunker. The key lesson from the book is that however smart its leaders may be, and however much testing they do, in reality, Facebook knows little more about what will work than the rest of us. Their difference is that the whole company is set up not just to cope with failure, but also to actively court it. The company motto of ‘Move fast and break things’ gives them the freedom to change their mind whenever they feel like it. And if one of those things that they break is the social media dream, then so be it. Facebook is currently valued at US $500 billion.

PS: By coincidence, our digital team has found a way to get close to 100 percent organic reach for brands. We realise that it’s only a matter of time before Facebook swoop in and knock it back again so we’re keeping it under our hats.

*James Del. Gawker.

  • Paul Catmur is the founder and CEO of Barnes, Catmur & Friends Dentsu.

This is a community discussion forum. Comment is free but please respect our rules:

  1. Don’t be abusive or use sweary type words
  2. Don’t break the law: libel, slander and defamatory comments are forbidden
  3. Don’t resort to name-calling, mean-spiritedness, or slagging off
  4. Don’t pretend to be someone else.

If we find you doing these things, your comments will be edited without recourse and you may be asked to go away and reconsider your actions.
We respect the right to free speech and anonymous comments. Don’t abuse the privilege.

TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards 2019: Auckland Council's Emily Thorn named Rookie Marketer of the Year
features

TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards 2019: Auckland Council's Emily Thorn named Rookie Marketer of the Year

Since 2016, Emily Thorn, a marketing and publicity specialist for Auckland Council, has quickly excelled in marketing with ideas that cut through the marketplace. It’s no surprise her colleagues call her a driven, strategic and creative marketer who is a real asset to the team.

NZ Rugby and Sky team up in new broadcast deal

  • Media
  • October 14, 2019
  • Radio New Zealand
NZ Rugby and Sky team up in new broadcast deal
Photo: PHOTOSPORT

New Zealand Rugby is to take a 5 percent stake in Sky as it unveils a new broadcast deal.

Read more
DB Breweries spreads its wings, wins Supreme at TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards
awards

DB Breweries spreads its wings, wins Supreme at TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards

To turn Tui’s fortunes around, DB Breweries brewed up a new drink, and while it sports the Tui logo, it’s not a beer.

topics
Story IQ
Story IQ
Story IQ is a brand story consultancy. We help brands uncover the hidden, untold stories ...
Up-and-Comers
Up-and-Comers
We give the mic to the industry's future leaders to hear their thoughts on media, ...
Insight Creative
Insight Creative
Insight Creative specialises in shaping business stories out the core insights that often lie under ...
The Stoppies 2018
The Stoppies 2018
In February (Valentine's Day to be exact), StopPress gathered the industry for an evening of ...
Follow The Money
Follow The Money
Follow the money. It’s an axiom that journalists have believed in for years and a ...
Regional Rundown
Regional Rundown
StopPress takes a trip down the country to see who the audiences and agencies are ...
Beyond the Page 2018
Beyond the Page 2018
In conjunction with the MPA, the Beyond the Page series shows how some of the ...
Beneath the Surface
Beneath the Surface
In this series, brought to you by Microsoft, we talk to a conceptual photographer, illustrator ...
20/20 (tele)vision
20/20 (tele)vision
Media consumption is changing. But by how much?
The Hot List
The Hot List
Our rundown of the hottest shows, brands and creators in New Zealand media. 1. magazine ...
Cannes Lions 2017
Cannes Lions 2017
All the winners, the shortlists and the drama from this year's edition of advertising biggest ...
Merger Mania
Merger Mania
All our stories on the nation's two failed mergers in one place
Bauer Beyond the Page
Bauer Beyond the Page
When it comes to creating branded content, there are few better in the Kiwi market ...
The Indies
The Indies
Over the course of this series of articles, we look at how always-nimble indy agencies ...
AdRoll on automation
AdRoll on automation
Marketing automation is tipped to eventually become the only way advertising is traded in the ...
Game Changers
Game Changers
It’s all about PEOPLE. Join us as we discuss global insights, ideas and innovations from ...
TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards 2015
TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards 2015
Celebrating all the winners of the 2015 TVNZ-NZ Marketing Awards.
Future Tense
Future Tense
In a new series, StopPress talks to a range of newsmakers currently trying to shine ...
Beyond the Page
Beyond the Page
In conjunction with the MPA, the Beyond the Page series shows how some of the ...
Up Country
Up Country
In conjunction with News Works, the Up Country series talks with some of New Zealand's ...
Sounding off
Sounding off
As part of a content partnership with MediaWorks, we've asked a few of the company's ...
StopPress Podcasts
StopPress Podcasts
We sit down for a chat with industry leaders to find out what they're up ...

Women Who Lead: In conversation with Motion Sickness head of strategy Hilary Ngan Kee (watch)

  • Women who Lead
  • October 10, 2019
  • Idealog
Women Who Lead: In conversation with Motion Sickness head of strategy Hilary Ngan Kee (watch)

In the first of a series highlighting the vibrant women in New Zealand business doing great things in their respective fields, Elly Strang, editor of Idealog profiles Hilary Ngan Kee, the head of strategy and a director at award-winning agency Motion Sickness.

Read more
When is a prescribed solution not the right answer?
Sponsored content

When is a prescribed solution not the right answer?

Sometimes the brief can miss the mark when expectations are too tight. Here, Insight Creative tells us how the prescribed solution isn’t always the best course of action.

voices

Social scoreboard

Zavy and StopPress have worked together to create a scoreboard that compares how the top 25 traditional media advertising spenders in New Zealand have performed on social media over the past 30 days, updated in real time.

Spark Sport wins broadcast rights to NZ Cricket fixtures

  • Media
  • October 10, 2019
  • Radio New Zealand
Spark Sport wins broadcast rights to NZ Cricket fixtures

Spark Sport says it has broadcast rights to NZ Cricket fixtures from April 2020 with TVNZ as free to air partner.

Read more

Huffer and the Mental Health Foundation get lyrical about mental health

  • Advertising
  • October 10, 2019
  • StopPress Team
Huffer and the Mental Health Foundation get lyrical about mental health

Huffer has partnered with the Mental Health Foundation and Kiwi musicians support mental health awareness in a musical campaign by Reload & Smoke.

Read more

Education New Zealand aims to answer the tough questions

  • Advertising
  • October 9, 2019
  • StopPress Team
Education New Zealand aims to answer the tough questions

Education New Zealand has shinned the light on some of the joys of studying on our shores with the help of Special Group. The campaign message encourages potential international students to 'Ask New Anything', as they hear the benefits of studying in New Zealand from past students.

Read more

Stanley St Wellington welcomes five local hires

  • Movings/Shakings
  • October 9, 2019
  • StopPress Team
Stanley St Wellington welcomes five local hires

Stanley St has put a focus on local talent acquisitions. It's introducing five new roles into its Wellington office, including Aaron White as head of Stanley St Wellington.

Read more

Simply the best: the supreme winners of the 21st Best Design Awards

  • Awards
  • October 9, 2019
  • Idealog
Simply the best: the supreme winners of the 21st Best Design Awards

The 2019 Best Awards was held at the Spark Arena on Friday night celebrating the crème de la crème of the design industry. It recognised designers, young and old, for their craft across a range of categories, from graphic to moving image to product design. Most who attended were in agreement that the night was a blast, and resembled the maturing success of the design industry in Aotearoa. Here is a breakdown of the supreme winners.

Read more

Shine welcomes Richard Maddocks and Andy Schick to its team

  • Advertising
  • October 9, 2019
  • StopPress Team
Shine welcomes Richard Maddocks and Andy Schick to its team
Richard Maddocks, Andy Schick

Shine has welcomed Richard Maddocks to its team as chief creative officer and Andy Schick as digital director.

Read more

Have your say on StopPress comments

  • Gratuitous self-promotion
  • October 8, 2019
  • Erin McKenzie
Have your say on StopPress comments

In the wake of comments in bad taste making their way into StopPress' comment section, we want to know what you think of the platform and how you'd like to see it used in the future.

Read more
How Phantom Lab is mixing art and innovation
Sponsored content

How Phantom Lab is mixing art and innovation

From treasure hunts to lenticular images and interactive posters, Phantom Billstickers is generating attention for advertisers and entertaining passerby’s. We talk to its marketing manager Ben Stonyer about Phantom Labs, its creative hub that’s disrupting out-of-home space.

One to watch: whizz kid Eli Smit

  • Media
  • October 8, 2019
  • Eli Smit
One to watch: whizz kid Eli Smit

What would you think if a 10-year-old approached you for an interview? Eli Smit is rubbing shoulders with New Zealand entrepreneurs in his Ground Breaking podcast as well as running his own business Get Mowed. This kid is one to watch.

Read more

Ads of the week: 8 October

  • TVC of the week
  • October 8, 2019
  • StopPress Team
Ads of the week: 8 October

Everybody jazz hands for NZTA, Abes Bagels and the Breast Cancer Foundation.

Read more
Next page
Results for
Topics
Jobs
About

StopPress provides essential industry news and intelligence, updated daily. And the digital newsletter delivers the latest news to your inbox twice a week — for free!

©2009–2019 ICG Media. All rights reserved.
Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy policy.

Advertise

Contact Vernene Medcalf at +64 21 628 200 to advertise in StopPress.

View Media Kit